Quantcast
Channel: Get Schooled
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 78

Question isn’t just why schools use corporal punishment more on black students. Why use it at all?

$
0
0
A reported released Thursday confirms much of the earlier research on discipline in our schools: African-American students in Georgia are twice as likely as white students to be disciplined by corporal punishment.
BARRIE MAGUIRE/NEWSARTThe usual rebuttal here on the blog is that African-American students may be twice as likely to misbehave, but studies show even for the same transgressions, black kids pay a higher price.
I have made my view clear in many earlier blogs: Schools should never use corporal punishment.  Never. Ever.
Only a handful of states, including Georgia and most other Southern states, still allow it. I can’t understand the rationale that whacking kids helps them. Yes, I have heard state leaders, including Zell Miller, look back with nostalgia on the “whuppings” they earned as children, saying the paddle, cane or switch helped them straighten up and fly right.
Personal anecdotes aside, no support exists in the research or in common sense for using violence to improve behavior. Schools should not physically discipline children. Suspend them. Call the parents. Send them home. Don’t hit them.Georgia schools need to take a hard look at their discipline data. It’s not just that black students are being struck more; they are being suspended and expelled more for offenses earning white students lighter reprimands.

For the 2011-2012 school year, African-American students represented 37 percent of all the students enrolled in Georgia but made up 54 percent of students receiving in-school suspension, 66 percent of those getting out-of-school suspension, and 50 percent of those expelled.

According to the AJC:

The Brookings Institution report, citing federal education department data, found 1 out of 100 black students in Georgia were struck by a teacher or staffer during the 2011-12 school year, the most recent school year available. By comparison, 1 of 200 white Georgia students were struck during the same school year. White students outnumber black students in Georgia’s public school students, according to state education department data.

Only three states — Alabama, Arkansas and Mississippi — had a higher rate of black students who were disciplined by corporal punishment, the study found.

“So long as these failures fall disproportionately on black children, we are not yet living up to the dream that ‘children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character,’ ” the report said.

 

Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 78

Trending Articles